Feature Inventory¶

Every feature of the original, one row each, with where it lives and what happens to it.

Status key


✅	Fully implemented in the original
⚠️	Partial, emergent, or vestigial
❌	Named by the master plan but absent — new design work
🚫	Present, but deliberately not carried forward

Disposition key


Keep	Behaviour preserved, reimplemented
Keep+	Behaviour preserved and deliberately extended
New	No legacy behaviour to preserve
Drop	Not carried forward

Core framework¶

Feature	Status	Legacy location	Disposition
Gamemode bootstrap / loader	✅	`sh_init.lua`	Drop — D-13
File-prefix realm convention (`sv_`/`cl_`/`sh_`)	✅	`sh_init.lua:105`	Keep the intent (explicit realm), drop the mechanism
Configuration	✅	`sh_config.lua` (25 KB)	Keep+ — becomes typed, validated, hot-reloadable
Enumerations	✅	`sh_enumerations.lua`	Drop — C# enums
Logging with categories	✅	`libraries/sh_log.lua` (202)	Keep — `EVENT_*` taxonomy, access-gated viewer, file dump
Timers	✅	`gamemode/timer.lua`	Keep `timer.Conditional` as the interaction primitive
Plugin loader	✅	`libraries/sh_plugin.lua`	Drop — ADR-0002
Hook dispatch	🚫	monkey-patched `hook.Call`	Drop — D-07
Help registry	✅	`libraries/sh_help.lua`	Keep+ — generated from command metadata
Event enumerations	✅	`sh_events.lua`	Drop
Unit tests	❌	—	New
Dependency injection	❌	—	New
State machine	❌	—	New
Resource manager	❌	—	New — S&box asset system

Character¶

Feature	Status	Legacy location	Disposition
Player record	✅	`metatables/sv_player.lua` (965)	Keep the data, redesign entirely
Character creation	❌	—	New — a character is a Steam account
Multiple characters / selection / deletion	❌	—	New
Identity, description, biography	❌	—	New
Attributes, skills	❌	—	New
Appearance	⚠️	gender only, `_Gender`	New
Player models	✅	per-job, in `sh_jobs.lua`	Keep the per-job concept
Health	✅	engine + ragdoll health	Keep
Money	✅	`_Money`	Keep
Permissions	✅	`_Access` flag string	Keep+ — named permissions
Statistics	⚠️	frags/deaths only (`savefragsdeaths`)	New
Inventory ownership	✅	`_Inventory`	Keep, redesigned
Blacklists (timed, per-category)	✅	`_Blacklist`	Keep — good design
Clan tag	✅	`_Clan`	Keep
Donator tier	✅	`_Donator`	Keep
Lifecycle: join / leave / death / respawn	✅	`init.lua`, `hooks/`	Keep
Idle kick	✅	15 min, in the tick	Keep
Stuck-in-world detection	✅	in the tick	Keep

Inventory and items¶

Feature	Status	Legacy location	Disposition
Inventory storage	✅	flat `{id = count}`	Drop — ADR-0006
Space budget (40 units)	✅	`libraries/sv_inventory.lua`	Keep
Negative-size capacity items (pockets)	✅	`items/misc/small_pocket.lua`	Keep — excellent
Weight	❌	—	New (optional; space may remain the only axis)
Stacking	✅	implicit in the storage shape	Keep+ — becomes explicit opt-in
Per-item carry limits	🚫	`ITEM.Max` — dead code	Keep the intent, D-03
Single mutation choke point	✅	`cider.inventory.update`	Keep
`onUpdate` escape hatch	🚫	same	Drop — D-12
Client mirror	⚠️	delta-only, desyncs	Drop — D-05
Item definitions as data	⚠️	Lua files with implicit ID/category	Keep the authoring feel, ADR-0004
Item inheritance (`Base`)	⚠️	single-level; array form broken	Keep+ — validated, D-04
Item categories	✅	directory-derived, `CATEGORY_*`	Keep — jobs gate on these
World items (one entity for all)	✅	`cider_item`	Keep
Use / drop / destroy / sell / pickup	✅	`metatables/sv_item.lua`	Keep
Per-item state (durability, ammo, contents)	❌	impossible by construction	New
Drag/drop, sorting, splitting, combining	❌	`/inventory` command only	New
Nested containers	⚠️	`packaging` crates, one level	New
Containers	✅	`libraries/sv_container.lua`	Keep, unified with inventory
Map-authored container capacities	✅	`config["Spawnable Containers"]`	Keep — scarcity
Virtual/computed container contents	✅	`PlayerGetContainerContents` hook	Keep — enables banking
Container permissions (`CAN_PUT`/`CAN_TAKE`)	✅	`sh_enumerations.lua`	Keep
Contents dumped on container destruction	✅	`CallOnRemove`	Keep

Interaction¶

Feature	Status	Legacy location	Disposition
Universal interaction framework	❌	—	New
Timed interaction with cancel predicate	✅	`timer.Conditional`, weapon equip	Keep — becomes the general primitive
Use / pickup / drop	✅	scattered	Unify
Open / close / lock / unlock	✅	`libraries/sv_entity.lua`	Unify
Search	⚠️	container UI only	New
Lockpick	✅	`cider_lockpick`, cumulative wear	Keep — wear mechanic
Breach	✅	`cider_breach`, 60 s jam	Keep
Repair / break / hack	❌	—	New
Talk / trade	⚠️	chat and `/givemoney` on trust	Keep the lack of escrow
Eat / drink	⚠️	eat only; drinks restore hunger	Keep+

World objects¶

Feature	Status	Legacy location	Disposition
Entity ownership (player/team/gang)	✅	`libraries/sv_entity.lua` (812)	Keep
Per-entity access lists	✅	same	Keep
Hierarchical gang access (`group;0`)	✅	`hasAccess`	Keep
Access surviving disconnect	✅	`saveAccess`/`restoreAccess`	Keep
Doors	✅	same + `plugins/doors`	Keep
Door state bitfield	🚫	`DTInt(3)`	Drop — D-16
Master/slave door linking	✅	`setMaster` etc.	Keep+ — becomes property groups
Sealing	✅	`OBJ_SEALED`, `/seal`	Keep
Jamming / autoclose	✅	60 s / 10 s	Keep
Padlocks as physical entities	✅	`cider_padlock`	Keep
Entity naming	✅	`/setname`	Keep
Lights, switches, furniture, generators, workbenches	❌	—	New
Vehicles	✅	`plugins/vehicles` (1061 lines)	Deferred — see ROADMAP

Needs¶

Feature	Status	Legacy location	Disposition
Two-rate tick (0.1 s / 1 s)	✅	`libraries/sv_player.lua`	Keep
Hunger	✅	`plugins/hunger`	Keep (invert polarity)
Hunger: vehicle double damage	✅	same	Keep
Hunger: suicide/respawn anti-exploit	✅	same	Keep exactly
Hunger: refuse to eat below 25	✅	`items/base/food.lua`	Keep
Stamina	✅	`plugins/stamina`	Keep
Stamina: injury coupling	✅	same	Keep — this is the injury system
Stamina: smooth speed interpolation	✅	same	Keep
Stamina: 1/50 exhaustion hysteresis	✅	same	Keep
`PlayerCanBeRecapacitated` gate	✅	same	Keep as a cancellable event
Passive healing while sleeping	✅	1 HP / 2 s, in the tick	Keep
Thirst	❌	—	New (a `drinks` category already exists)
Temperature	❌	—	New
Disease	❌	—	New
Bleeding	⚠️	cosmetic decals; timer bug	Keep+ — make it mechanical
Injuries	⚠️	emergent only	New
Healing	⚠️	`drugs` items + sleep	Keep+
Needs persistence	❌	reset on every join	New

Economy¶

Feature	Status	Legacy location	Disposition
Money (integer, floor 0, no debt)	✅	`meta:GiveMoney`	Keep
Salary + payday	✅	`init.lua:1418`	Keep
Salary withheld while dead or arrested	✅	same	Keep
Donator salary multiplier	✅	`init.lua:711`	Keep
Contraband interval income	✅	300 s, `init.lua:1412`	Keep
Contraband refill warnings	✅	same	Keep
Contraband per-player caps	✅	`items/base/contraband.lua`	Keep
Tiered contraband	⚠️	`Applejack` fork only	Keep+ — input to crafting
Manufacturing (`/manufacture`)	✅	`sv_commands.lua:1097`	Keep the rules, replace the system
Role monopoly by item category	✅	`canmake` per team	Keep — this is the whole economy
Physical shipments spawned in world	✅	`item:Make` at eye trace	Keep
Cost and cooldown scale with batch	✅	same	Keep
Universal 50% refund	✅	doors and items	Keep
Door tax with repossession	✅	payday loop	Keep
Player trade (no escrow)	✅	`/givemoney`, `/dropmoney`	Keep the risk
Banks	❌	hook exists, bank never built	New
Vendors / NPC shops	❌	—	New
Licences	❌	—	New
Death money penalty	🚫	`Death Penalty = 2`, marked unused	Drop

Crime¶

Feature	Status	Legacy location	Disposition
Mechanism / gate / policy split	✅	metatable / hooks / `officials`	Keep — best decision in the codebase
Warrants (search 5 min, arrest 1 h)	✅	`meta:Warrant`	Keep
Warrant persistence	❌	dies on restart	New
Arrest (5 min, persistent)	✅	`meta:Arrest`	Keep
Cannot log out of jail	✅	`loadFunctions._Arrested`	Keep (fix the timer arithmetic)
Confiscation vs disarming	✅	`TakeWeapons(noitems)`	Keep the distinction
Jail points per map	✅	`plugins/prisonpoints`	Keep
Knockout with posed ragdoll	✅	`meta:KnockOut`	Keep
Ragdoll has its own health	✅	`ply.ragdoll.health`	Keep
Position follows the ragdoll	✅	`sh_player.lua` `GetPos` override	Keep the behaviour, not the override
Tying with struggle meter	✅	`meta:TieUp`	Keep
Incapacitate primitive	✅	`meta:Incapacitate`	Keep
Blood trails	⚠️	decals; timer bug	Keep+
Tranquilliser	✅	`cider_tranq`	Keep
Lockpicking with cumulative wear	✅	`cider_lockpick`	Keep
Ten player-authored laws	✅	`libraries/sh_laws.lua`	Keep — code must never read them
Law change cooldown (120 s)	✅	same	Keep
Evidence	❌	—	New
Fines	❌	—	New
Criminal records	❌	—	New
Bail / trials / sentencing	❌	fixed 300 s	New

Jobs and factions¶

Feature	Status	Legacy location	Disposition
Group → gang → team hierarchy	✅	`libraries/sh_team.lua`	Keep
Gang 0 = group general population	✅	`hasAccess`	Keep
Numeric levels driving demotion	✅	`TEAM.level`	Keep
Governance flags (`b`/`d`/`g`/`D`/`M`)	✅	`sh_jobs.lua`	Keep
Mandatory transit class (`M`)	✅	`Master Race` config	Keep
Demotion (needs 5 in gang)	✅	`meta:Demote`	Keep
Mutiny (needs 4, 75% approval)	✅	`/mutiny`	Keep
Per-job player caps	✅	`maxplayers`	Keep
Job time limits and rejoin cooldowns	✅	`{maxJobTime, rejoin}`	Keep
Job blacklisting	✅	`_Blacklist`	Keep
Loadouts and ammo per job	✅	`sh_jobs.lua`	Keep
Symmetric rival gangs	✅	Rogues / Renegades	Keep
15 positional parameters	🚫	`cider.team.add`	Drop — becomes an asset
Presentation order = file order	🚫	`sh_jobs.lua`	Drop — explicit sort key

Chat and commands¶

Feature	Status	Legacy location	Disposition
Single gated, logged entry point	✅	`concommand "cider"`	Keep the shape
`PlayerCanUseCommand` global veto	✅	`libraries/sv_commands.lua`	Keep
Help auto-registered from commands	✅	same	Keep+ — fully generated
`return false, message` failure convention	✅	same	Keep
Every command logged with arguments	✅	`EVENT_COMMAND`	Keep
66 commands	✅	`sv_commands.lua` (58 KB)	Keep the vocabulary, split the file
Proximity IC chat (256 units)	✅	`Talk Radius`	Keep
Proximity voice	✅	`Local Voice`	Keep
Channels (`/y` `/w` `/me` `/ooc` `/looc` …)	✅	`sv_commands.lua`	Keep
OOC cooldown (60 s), advert cost ($60/150 s)	✅	config	Keep the friction
Roleplay affordances (`/sleep` `/trip` `/fallover`)	✅	same	Keep
Notification levels (4 sounds)	✅	`meta:Notify`	Keep the taxonomy
Physical notes (max 2)	✅	`/note`, `cider_note`	Keep
Stringly-typed variadic arguments	🚫	same	Drop — D-02

UI¶

Feature	Status	Legacy location	Disposition
Custom chatbox	✅	`libraries/cl_chatbox.lua` (924)	Rebuild in Razor
Bottom bars extension point	✅	`DrawBottomBars`	Keep as an API
Top text extension point	✅	`DrawTopText`	Keep
ESP lines on look	✅	`AdjustESPLines`	Keep — primary information channel
Inventory panel	✅	`derma/`	Rebuild
Door / access panels	✅	`cl_door.lua`, `cl_access.lua`	Rebuild
Laws panel	✅	`cl_laws.lua`	Rebuild
Scoreboard	✅	`gamemode/scoreboard/`	Rebuild
Log viewer (access-gated)	✅	`libraries/sh_log.lua`	Keep
Derma layouts	🚫	`derma/`	Drop entirely

Weapons¶

Feature	Status	Legacy location	Disposition
Shared weapon base	✅	`entities/weapons/rg_base`	Rebuild
17 weapons	✅	`entities/weapons/`	Rebuild as data
Holster slots (1 large, 2 small)	✅	`_GunCounts`, config	Keep
Timed equip, cancelled by movement	✅	`items/base/weapon.lua`	Keep — the interaction model
Deploy cooldown	✅	`_NextDeploy`	Keep
Ammo as items	✅	`items/ammo/`	Keep
Weapons dropped on police kill	✅	`Police Kill Drop`	Keep
Damage scaling (head ×5, chest ×2, limb ×0.75)	✅	config	Keep
Anti-propkill	✅	config	Drop (no prop sandbox)
Attachments, jamming	❌	—	New
Melee, thrown	⚠️	baton, knife	Keep

Not present at all¶

Feature	Master plan phase	Notes
NPC framework	14	`items/base/npc.lua` exists; no AI
Crafting	15	`/manufacture` is a purchase, not crafting
Housing	16	Emergent from door ownership only
Medical	10	`drugs` category + sleep regen
Character creation	5	—
Banks	11	The enabling hook was built; the bank was not
Automated tests	22	—

Summary¶

Of the master plan's 24 phases, the original provides:

Strong, well-tuned behaviour for: inventory, items, doors and property, jobs and factions, crime and policing, chat and commands, hunger and stamina, and the economy's role-monopoly structure.
Partial or emergent behaviour for: injuries, healing, trading, nested containers, bleeding.
Nothing at all for: character creation, NPCs, crafting, housing, medical, banks, vendors, evidence, and every form of automated testing.

Roughly 60% of the master plan is new design work. The 40% that exists is worth studying closely, because its tuning is the product of years of live play — and that tuning, not its code, is the thing being preserved.